Random Thoughts

The Deal-With-It-Ism Trap

For roughly a thousand years, Chinese women had their feet broken and bound — toes folded under the sole, wrapped in tight cloth, reshaped over months into a tapered point about three inches long. The practice began in the Song dynasty and persisted well into the twentieth century. It was excruciatingly painful, permanently debilitating, and nearly universal. A woman with unbound feet was, in practical terms, unmarriageable.

If you were a young woman in, say, 1850 — smart, clear-eyed, fully aware that this tradition was cruel — what would you hear when you voiced that awareness?

“That’s just how things are. You can either bind your feet and have a life, or don’t and accept the consequences.”

This response is factually correct. It’s also a perfectly useless thing to say. It takes the current state of the world and presents it as a boundary condition — a fixed constraint to be optimized around, not a problem to be questioned. The person saying it isn’t wrong. They’re just done thinking too early.

I’ve started calling this pattern deal-with-it-ism: the reflexive treatment of a broken system as a fixed landscape — something to be navigated, never questioned. It’s the instinct to skip past “should this be the case?” and jump straight to “given that it is, what do you do?”


The instinct to adapt

We all do this. It’s not a character flaw — it’s a survival instinct. You don’t philosophize about the nature of fire while your kitchen is burning. Deal-with-it-ism is genuinely useful in a huge number of situations, and the people who are good at it tend to be the ones who keep teams running and projects shipping.

The problem is when it becomes the only mode of thinking available — when every observation that the system itself might be broken gets flattened into advice for how to operate within it.

Point out that a game’s difficulty spike is poorly designed? “Get good.” Raise a concern about architectural debt in a codebase? “We need to ship. File a ticket.” Question whether a hiring process selects for the wrong traits? “That’s the process. Prep better.”

The pattern is always the same: the system disappears from view, and what remains is you — and your apparent inability to deal with reality. A critique of the terrain gets repackaged as a deficiency of the hiker. The system you’re optimizing within is itself beyond question.


Coherence as progress

I think the ability to notice incoherence is part of how civilization progresses.

Consider the arc of civilization, and ask: what actually changes? Technology changes, obviously. Laws change. Norms change. But underneath all of that, there’s a subtler, slower process: we get better at noticing when things don’t cohere.

Sometimes that’s a contradiction between values. We used to believe in human dignity and watch gladiators kill each other for entertainment. We used to believe in equality and practice slavery. We used to believe children deserve protection and send them into coal mines. Each of these was resolved by someone noticing: these two things we both believe cannot both be true.

Sometimes it’s a gap between capability and reality. We had the technology to put a computer in every pocket for years before anyone built the thing that made people actually want one. The pre-iPhone world wasn’t morally inconsistent — but it was incoherent. What we could do and what we were doing didn’t match. Someone felt that tension before they could articulate it, and the articulation became a product.

Sometimes it’s simpler still — just the persistent, nagging sense that something could be better than it is, without a clear framework for why. A designer plays a hundred games that handle inventory the same way, and something about it has always bothered her, and one day she builds something different and it’s obviously right.

The common thread across all of these isn’t the specific domain. It’s the sensitivity: the ability to feel that two things don’t cohere — values and actions, capability and reality, what-is and what-could-be — before you have the language to prove it.

This is also why every product that genuinely succeeds is, at some level, the resolution of an incoherence. Sometimes it’s a market gap identified through analysis, but more often than not, a felt gap, experienced by someone who lived inside the problem long enough to sense the shape of what was missing. The need existed before the product did. The product was the articulation.

This is what I’d call wisdom in the civilizational sense — not the accumulation of knowledge, but the progressive elimination of incoherence. Not only the moral kind — the “we say we believe X but we do Y” kind — but also the generative kind: the distance between how things are and how they could be. There’s a mathematical elegance to this: in formal logic, a system with a contradiction can prove anything — ex falso quodlibet. Every incoherence you eliminate is one fewer license to rationalize, one fewer way for a bad argument or a bad product to survive unchallenged. Progress, in this framing, is the slow tightening of what we can say with a straight face — and the slow expansion of what we can build with a clear conscience.


What gives the work its purpose

That sensitivity often begins before we can clearly describe what is wrong. Giving it words, rules, or a design makes it easier to act on. AI is increasingly able to help with that work.

Over the past two years, a specific kind of professional confidence has been collapsing: “Sure, AI is impressive, but it can’t do X.” Write production-quality code. Understand a large codebase. Work autonomously with real tools. As those capabilities improve, it becomes harder to ground human value in a list of tasks machines supposedly cannot do.

What remains essential is the human experience that gives this work its purpose. This doesn’t require a prediction about what AI will never be able to do.

AI can write a song that people call good. It might also invent something radically unfamiliar that people discover they love. There’s no need to draw a permanent boundary around its creativity. But whether the song moves someone depends on the person listening. An AI’s assessment of its own work, however sophisticated, cannot establish that for them.

The same applies to the dissatisfaction that prompts us to change something. “Does this bother you?” and “Is this new thing good enough?” are questions whose answers matter because they come from the people living with the problem and using the solution. AI can notice a pattern we’ve missed, help articulate a frustration, or propose an improvement before anyone asks for one. It can predict our answers with increasing accuracy. Those predictions remain accountable to what we actually experience.

Even if AI eventually develops something resembling feelings, its feelings won’t settle whether a game is fun for us, whether a tool makes our work easier, or whether an arrangement we’re expected to tolerate is making us miserable. When the purpose is to improve human lives, human experience is the criterion. People may disagree, and their preferences may change through encountering something new. That doesn’t make their responses incidental to the process.

The process often begins with someone feeling an incoherence, struggling to articulate it, and eventually finding a way to address it. AI can help throughout, including with identifying the problem and evaluating possible solutions. As generation becomes cheaper, we can explore more possibilities. But we still need to care whether something bothers people, and whether what we’ve made is actually better for them.


The trap

Deal-with-it-ism suppresses that sensitivity. Someone feels an incoherence that hasn’t been formalized yet, and deal-with-it-ism says: stop. Don’t feel that. Adapt.

It trains you to ignore your own sense that something doesn’t cohere, even though that experience is part of what any proposed improvement needs to answer to. Not through argument, but through social pressure. You learn that noticing brokenness is naïve. That questioning the system is a luxury. That the mature, serious, professional thing to do is to navigate the terrain as given and save your energy for things you can control.

This was always a bad trade. But it was at least a legible one. The system-navigators had real skills — hard-won, valuable, respected. They kept things running. They shipped. In a world where execution was expensive and generation was slow, knowing how to work within constraints wasn’t just practical; it was the whole game.

That world is ending.

As AI makes more of that work easier, knowing how to navigate an existing system is less sufficient on its own. There is still real skill in execution. But greater capacity to build makes it all the more important to ask what is worth building, and whose experience it should improve.

What doesn’t depreciate is the thing deal-with-it-ism was designed to suppress: the ability to feel that something is wrong before you can prove it. The willingness to stay with that discomfort instead of explaining it away. The stubbornness to keep thinking when everyone around you has stopped.

Deal-with-it-ism told you to stop caring about the things you couldn’t fix. That was always bad advice. Now it’s obsolete advice. The thing that will matter most — the thing that already matters most — is the part of you that refuses to look at something broken and call it fine.

Start caring.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *